Exploring Violence, Non-violence & Extinction Rebellion - where XR gets the research wrong

Watch on YouTube

Show annotations

2,584

121

2

Genre: People & Blogs

Family friendly? Yes

Wilson score: 0.9426

Rating: 4.935 / 5

Engagement: 4.76%

We Only Want the Earth

Subscribe | 281

Shared June 27, 2019

Disagreements about the role of violence in political movements is at least as old as those movements. Extinction Rebellion have tried to short cut such discussions through reference to a piece of research they suggest shows non-violent movements are twice as successful in achieving their objectives. In this episode of We Only Want the Earth I examine what this paper actually claims and use this as a way to talk about non-violence and recent radical political movements.

It's a journey that will take us through the research paper itself to the Northern Ireland Civil Rights Movement, the murderous state repression of Bloody Sunday 1972, Reclaim the Streets and the summit protests of the early 2000s to argue that simplified versions of tactical debates around non-violence are worse than useless and do nothing to prepare XR activists for the years of struggle ahead.



13:39

Life inside Extinction Rebellion: 'We can't get arrested quick enough'

177K views

1:03:09

EXTINCTION REBELLION FOUNDER ROGER HALLAM - Long Interview

3.1K views

32:15

The Nonsense Politics of PragerU | Big Joel

823K views

15:48

Fighting with non-violence | Scilla Elworthy

238K views

27:28

How NON-VIOLENCE protects the STATE (Peter Gelderloos)

40K views

46:15

Harvey Weinstein: The fall of the king of Hollywood

2.1M views

41:20

Leading in a Climate Changed World - with Dr Gail Bradbrook | Extinction Rebellion

7.2K views

22:13

XR Talks | Roger Hallam | Non-Violent Direct Action - Extinction Rebellion

10K views

22:07

Cocos Island - The mysterious island in the Pacific

1.2M views

28:32

Will Germany's car industry survive? | DW Documentary

776K views

10:07

Extinction Rebellion - questions & criticisms

5.4K views

1:46:10

'Heading for Extinction' - Oxford Extinction Rebellion talk with George Monbiot and friends.

45K views

27:43

The Collapse of the American Empire?

3.2M views

18:46

What hallucination reveals about our minds | Oliver Sacks

3.4M views

8:31

‘All of us are in danger’: John Pilger delivers warning from Julian Assange

692K views

50:01

Devil's Island : Colonies of the Condemned

3.4M views

8:48

DAVID ICKE - WHO WERE THE 9/11 HIJACKERS? | London Real

81K views

21:14

Act as if the Truth is Real - Extinction Rebellion

32K views

51:40

Do This To Completely HEAL Your Body and Mind | Marisa Peer

163K views